All posts by Carmen Gomaro

Carmen Gomaro - leading international news and investigative reporter. Worked at various media outlets in Spain, Argentina and Colombia, including Diario de Cádiz, CNN+, Telemadrid and EFE.

Vox leaves its attendance at the PP event in Madrid up in the air but prepares a "great landing" on 8-O in Barcelona

Vox works in silence. Away from the noise, they say in Bambú, but with the calendar in hand. They know that the political future is going to be played largely in the streets, and that is why they assess how and in what concentrations against the amnesty to turn.. While waiting to learn more details about the “great event” announced by the Popular Party for Sunday, September 24, the protest that most convinces Vox is the one on October 8 in Barcelona organized by the Catalan Civil Society.

In fact, while Génova still does not confirm whether Alberto Núñez Feijóo will attend this demonstration – in which the participation of the Madrid president, Isabel Díaz Ayuso, is planned -, Vox is already preparing a “grand landing” of its leadership in Barcelona: Santiago Abascal and Ignacio Garriga, president and general secretary of the party, will lead a powerful delegation from the party, as confirmed by sources from the Vox apparatus.

The party already warned in recent days that it intended to be the political spearhead of demands in defense of the Constitution and compliance with the law, and in Bambú they define themselves as the only party that marks a real red line with nationalisms.. What's more, the PP's approach to Junts in recent days in an “informal” manner did not please the Vox management, which demanded explanations from the popular people about these contacts that have not yet arrived.

To know more
Opinion. Aznar and the committed coup plotters

Aznar and the committed coup plotters

In the same way that no more information has emerged about what the PP's plan is for Sunday, September 24, just a couple of days before the investiture of Alberto Núñez Feijóo.. As this newspaper publishes today, the majority of the territorial leaders of the PP plan to be present in Madrid. But Vox, which has not received any communication in this regard despite being a partner of the popular parties in six regions, has not decided for now whether or not it will attend an event that Génova defines as open in order to have the company of other parties. and associations.

In any case, the call in Barcelona pleases Vox management more than the one at the end of September for different reasons.. Firstly, because the convener is a platform and not a party, which gives a more civic than political spirit to the mobilization.. Secondly for the location. Vox boasts of being the main right-wing party in Catalonia and the most voted among the “constitutionalists”, a group from which the PSC is excluded.

In the last general elections Vox, despite falling into important fiefdoms, maintained its level in Catalonia. In fact, it has two valuable deputies in Congress for Barcelona.. Furthermore, the hard core of Abascal – who today will go to Murcia to accompany José Ángel Antelo in his inauguration as regional vice president – in the political leadership of the party, Ignacio Garriga and Jorge Buxadé, come from Catalonia and know the situation in depth. of politics in this region.

Finally, the calendar of this demonstration practically coincides in date with the void left by Viva, the festival that Vox has celebrated with its militancy for several years the second week of October and that this year, given the political uncertainty of the coming months , decided to postpone to spring. From the party, in any case, the organization of another event that temporarily fit on similar dates was not ruled out.

Otegi's international plan: a breakfast with consuls in Bilbao during the San Sebastián Film Festival

The nationalist left knows that it is a good time to take advantage of the delicate political situation that exists in Spain. And, through its satellites, it is already sending messages of some of the demands that it wants to put on the table in the negotiations to support the Government and the possible legislature.. But, in addition, faced with the weakness of a long period with an acting Executive, the radical nationalists also try to extend their tentacles to the international arena, a movement that they have always tried to carry out when ETA was active in its terrorist branch and that It bore important results in certain European countries that collaborated less intensely in the fight against ETA.

Thus, as EL MUNDO has learned, in recent weeks, Bildu has been inviting foreign legations to an event in Bilbao in which they want to present their vision “of the country” and explain what their political postulates are to move towards the independence of the Basque Country. His speech will be based on three axes. The first, defend the release of the ETA prisoners since they will defend again that they are “political prisoners.”. As an asset, they will expose the Government's movements to bring prisoners closer to prisons in the Basque Country and Navarra. His second postulate: the annexation of Navarra by the Basque Country. You will remember that the door is still open in the Constitution. And, finally, they will defend the independence of the Basque Country through a right to self-determination “of its people” and the possibility of remaining in the European Union.

An official invitation has been issued from the ranks of EH Bildu “to the first breakfast-meeting between our political formation and the consular corps,” the invitation explains.. «The meeting will be held at the Meliá Hotel in Bilbao, at 9:30 a.m. on September 29, just the eve of the closing of the San Sebastián Film Festival, this year surrounded by controversy over the broadcast of an interview with the ETA member. claimed by the National Court 'Josu Ternera'.

«The meeting is to get to know each other and present the work of Euskal Herria Bildu in the field of International Relations. The General Coordinator, Arnaldo Otegi, and the Senator and Director of International Relations, Gorka Elejabarrieta, will be present,” the invitation adds.

According to sources close to the event, the response is being very uneven.. In several of the consulates expected to be invited “they know nothing about the matter nor have they received any mail”. But they have received it from many Europeans who have already shown their reluctance to participate in political party events.. In some cases, they have previously chosen to send it to their embassy so that it can make the decision and they are waiting to receive responses.. This move by Bildu occurs just during the week of the San Sebastián film festival, one of the events in the Basque Country with the greatest international projection.. In this edition, in addition, it will start with a strong controversy especially in the world of victims of terrorism since an interview with 'Josu Ternera' will be broadcast at the opening, claimed for the attack against the barracks house of the Civil Guard of Zaragoza. Three civil guards and eight of their relatives were murdered, including five minors.. Another 88 people were injured.

Campaign against the Civil Guard

On the other hand, a new campaign against the Civil Guard is already starting from the publication pages of the nationalist left.. An article signed by the historic nationalist Patxi Zabaleta defends the demilitarization of the Civil Guard, which would later lead to its dissolution.. “They bark, then we ride,” goes the old Latin saying. The vociferous right does not defend the rank and file officials of the Civil Guard, but rather the character and military leadership of an institution, whose conditions partially prevented during the reform and continue to hinder democratically essential changes in democracy,” the former begins his text. Navarrese politician who was a founding member of the HB and Nafarroa Bai coalitions.

«I am convinced that if it were put to a vote among the rank and file guards, whether said body should stop being military and become civilian, the option of civilization would win, without a doubt. “Only such a change would imply the dissolution of the Civil Guard, as a military institute, and would entail the recognition of basic rights such as unionization, strike, opinion, assembly, etc.”

The chaos 24 hours after Montse Tomé's first list: without players, without coaching staff…

On August 25, five days after Luis Rubiales' non-consensual kiss with Jenni Hermoso, 81 soccer players, active and retired, announced, literally or symbolically, that they were resigning from the Spanish soccer team.. “All the players who sign this letter will not return to a call if the current leaders continue,” they stated in the joint statement.

20 days later, almost everything, but nothing, has changed in the Federation. Rubiales has resigned, Jorge Vilda has been fired and Montse Tomé, until August the coach's assistant, is now the new coach of the national team. But the highest organization of Spanish football has still not finalized the new organization chart for its women's football and the players still do not really believe the changes.. All, as if that were not enough, 24 hours from Tomé's first list, valid for the Nations League matches this September (the 22nd against Sweden in Göteborg and the 26th against Switzerland in Córdoba). A tournament that distributes two places for the next Olympic Games in Paris.

Maximum sporting pressure at a time of maximum social pressure. The backbone of the world champion team continues to think about its situation. They promised not to return until Rubiales and Vilda left, but the solution that the RFEF has offered them does not convince them: the vice president of the leader and the coach's assistant. They want to be in the Games, just as they wanted to win the World Cup, but they consider whether it is worth continuing to fight for more improvements. In recent days, Ana Álvarez, director of Women's Football of the Federation, has held various conversations with the locker room representatives to try to convince them to return, but the situation in Las Rozas is still not clear.

Rocha's attempts

This Friday Tomé, for whom the duration of her contract as coach is unknown, will give a list of which she does not yet know the available players nor has the RFEF announced the coaching staff that will be at her disposal.. There is no sports director of the women's section of the Federation, which until now was Vilda's position, nor is it known if the coaches and trainers who resigned at the end of August will return to their positions. Most of them finished their contract this year, so the situation is totally unpredictable.

Pedro Rocha, convinced of changing the image of Spanish football before it completely affects the Iberian candidacy for the 2030 World Cup, has personally tried to deal with the footballers and explain to them the structural changes he has planned for the RFEF, but he has not received a automatic response.

Luis Rubiales: "A criminal? Look at me. I'm a good person"

Luis Rubiales spoke for an hour about the 21 days that convulsed Spanish football. He did so with Piers Morgan, famous in the United Kingdom for his attacks against the feminist movement, in an interview, broadcast yesterday, where he reiterated his “humility to ask for forgiveness sincerely” and his commitment to dedicate himself to his defense “of the “cleanest possible”. When at one point in the talk, the British journalist asked him directly if Jenni Hermoso had lied, Rubiales opted for evasion.. “I'm not going to answer”.

Morgan started with the hottest topic, the kiss with Hermoso. «It is evident that I was wrong and I said it from the beginning. Jenni took me in the air and when we got off we were very excited. There was no intention or sexual connotation, only appreciation. “It was a simple mutual act of happiness and fusion,” explained Rubiales, who took his first steps with the Englishman in the summer of 2009, during his brief time at Hamilton Academy, in the Scottish Premiership.. Then, he launched his first salvo: “Many people have dedicated themselves to distorting and the truth has not reached everyone.”. “I don't respect those who misrepresent.”

To know more
Whispers of sport. The chain that ties Jenni Hermoso to the resigned Rubiales

The chain that ties Jenni Hermoso to the resigned Rubiales

Next, the former president of the RFEF lowered several tones by admitting that he was “really embarrassed” by his celebration in the box, with his hands on his testicles, a few meters from Queen Letizia and Infanta Sofía: “There are no excuses”. He even dared to explain to the Anglo-Saxon audience that this Olé your…. “It was directed” to former coach Jorge Vilda. “God forbid I comment on things about the Monarchy, but the entire Royal Family knows me,” he said before confirming that he had not yet had the opportunity to apologize to the Queen.

“She was praying for me”

True to his style, Morgan boldly went for the heartstrings. The one that vibrates in Rubiales when they lie to their daughters and their mother. “Yesterday I was with her in Motril and I brought her the ice cream that she likes,” he confessed about someone who had been on hunger strike for several days.. When he insisted on the possibility of a fatal outcome, the former Levante footballer revealed the health problems typical of a 72-year-old woman, such as hypertension. “I was very scared, but she was praying for me,” he concluded.

In another calculatedly emotional moment, the former editor of the Daily Mirror and News of The World tabloids asked if he had thought about going to jail. And Rubiales' response seemed up to the mark: “I remain confident that the whole truth will come to light.”. A criminal? Look at me. I'm a good person”. What he did not seem willing to forgive was the disloyalty of someone on the technical staff.. «He wrote to me gratefully and a couple of days later he signed the manifesto calling me a sexist.. “I will take these WhatsApp messages to court,” he said.

In the United Kingdom, the interview was broadcast by the TalkTV network, owned by tycoon Rupert Murdoch, whose poor audience records have multiplied rumors about its closure in recent weeks.. So one of Morgan's goals was to make sure the show didn't decline.. Rubiales “categorically” denied having pressured the Pachuca midfielder in that video broadcast during the return flight in Doha. Of course, when Morgan offered the possibility of a future apology in person with Hermoso, the former president of the RFEF was not at all conclusive.. «I have to defend my dignity with arguments. From the beginning I have maintained the same version and now I can only maintain it.

“A president cannot behave like that”

Morgan, who last November had achieved another exclusive interview in which Cristiano Ronaldo would settle accounts with the leaders of Manchester United, adjusted to his controversial profile during the conversation. In fact, he almost reprimanded the protagonist for so much apology.. However, Rubiales reiterated that his “behavior as president was not appropriate, although it was effusive and the result of emotion.”. “A president cannot behave like that in the box and can give a hug, although in a more diplomatic way,” he said.

Finally, the former presenter of Good Morning Britain, on the ITV network, from whom he was fired for his merciless attacks against Meghan Markle, got those two minutes, already leaked on Monday, where Rubiales confirmed his resignation. Rubiales spoke about the “media tsunami”, his love for Spain and the race for the 2030 World Cup. «I have had to endure a lot during these three weeks. “This decision can affect many people and it's not just about me.”. He also referred to his future projects. «I am young and I just want to be healthy and be with my family…. It could have been worse”.

And this only seems like the tip of the iceberg, because on Friday the 22nd Rubiales will repeat an interview with Alvise Pérez, a well-known propagator of hoaxes sentenced to compensate former minister José Luis Ábalos or former mayor Manuela Carmena.

Persa, the most veteran rescue dog of the EMU deployed in Morocco

Her name is Persian and she is the oldest rescue dog in the Military Emergency Unit (UME).. Along with 47 troops and three other canine companions from the 4th Battalion of the UME, based in Zaragoza, Persa has been deployed in Morocco to help search for the victims of the earthquake.. The earthquake that devastated the provinces of Al Houz on Friday, which includes Marrakech, Tarundant, Ouarzarzat, Chichaua, Azilal and its surroundings, and which reached an intensity of 7 on the Richter scale, is one of the most intense in recent history. from the neighboring country. It has already claimed almost 3,000 lives.

Corporal Julio Antonio Redondo guides Persa in his search for survivors in the rubble of Imi N'Tala. The intense smell of death that oozes from the ruins makes people fear that the people who are buried under their houses are no longer in the world of the living.. Even so, both – like the entire UME team – continue tirelessly insisting on every nook and cranny and putting all their effort into every centimeter of brush.

Imi N'Tala has been buried by the mountain and the houses have blocked the road, preventing access to the following villages. The landscape is imposing, full of gorges, now accentuated by the void left by the homes. The place, at almost 2,000 meters high, is part of the Tubkal National Geopark, the highest peak in Morocco at 4,167 meters.. It is one of the most followed routes for trekking lovers.

Persa and Corporal Redondo, accredited as a canine guide since 2009, are working under these conditions.. Redondo has several missions abroad and already has experience in high mountains, having participated in the rescue efforts during the earthquake in Nepal in April 2015.. Persa has worked on other searches before and is trained to act in major disasters.

“Persa is a Belgian Malinois, she is seven years old and is the oldest member of the Zaragoza team,” the corporal describes to his partner.. To be prepared for these missions, “training is daily, from Monday to Friday and even some weekends.”. It specializes in searching for snow avalanches and debris, such as earthquakes or attacks.. It can also work on banks, after a flood, when the water level drops it can detect if people have remained,” adds Redondo.

Persian's specialty is finding living people. The adobe that is built in the Amazigh villages of the Atlas does not leave any living spaces and collapses like a sand castle, preventing air chambers from being created.

Corporal Redondo and Persa search for survivors in Imi N'Tala. CARLOS GARCIA POZO

But as they say in the EMU, “hope is the last thing to be lost”. As an example, they mention the earthquake in Turkey last February, the last one in which Spanish specialists intervened, when they managed to rescue people alive seven days after the landslide.

“We train these dogs only to look for live people. But there are canine guides who prepare what we call dual dogs, which can detect both corpses or human remains and live people,” explains Redondo.. “The dog detects the cells, the breath, the smell that a person emanates when they are alive. “When a person dies, in approximately one hour the effluvia begins to emanate and the body decomposes and the dogs are able to detect that difference.”

Von der Leyen urges EU to "answer the call of history" and open the door to new members

“The time for determination has come and that means thinking about how to prepare for a complete Union. We need to overcome the old binary debates on enlargement. It is not about deepening integration or expanding the Union, since we can and must do both to give ourselves geopolitical weight and the ability to act.. This is what our Union has always done, since each wave of enlargement was accompanied by political deepening. We move from coal and steel to full economic integration. And after the fall of the Iron Curtain, we turned an economic project into a true Union of peoples and States. I believe that the next enlargement must also be a catalyst for progress. We began to build a Health Union at 27 and we can finish it with more than 30. We started building the European Defense Union at 27 and we can finish it with more than 30 members. We have shown that we can be a Geopolitical Union and we have shown that we can move quickly when we are united. The German, whose future is up in the air (she could repeat her position or become Secretary General of NATO next year), did not want to give dates for the enlargement, unlike the president of the European Council, Charles Michel, who two years ago weeks urged to make a move before 2030. He hasn't given specific names either, although Ukraine is now in the front row for obvious reasons.. And he has emphasized that it is a process that is based on merits and efforts and not only will.. But he has made it clear that there can be no alternative. “We are guided by the conviction that completing our Union is the best investment in peace, security and prosperity for our continent. “It is time for Europe to think big again and write its own destiny,” he urged.

Today's speech was not like Von der Leyen's three previous speeches before the Chamber.. The first were marked by a battery of proposals, concrete or indefinite, for their mandate.. Dozens of promises, aspirations and legislative initiatives for five years. Always with large figures of investments, funds or aid to fill headlines. Not this time. In 300 days, the Europeans will go to the polls, they will renew the European Parliament and the continental leaders will choose those responsible for the institutions until 2029, so their intervention has been one of balance and reflection.. Last year's speech had the motto “courage and solidarity”, completely focused on Ukraine and the war. This year's, with different types of aspirations, but perhaps even more ambition, personal and team, has been titled: “Responding to the call of history.”

“This is the time to decide what kind of future and what kind of Europe we want (…) Our Union today reflects the vision of those who dreamed of a better future after the Second World War. A future in which a Union of nations, democracies and peoples would work together to share peace and prosperity. They believed that Europe was the answer to the call of history and when I talk to the new generation of young people, I see the same vision of a better future, that same burning desire to build something better.. That same belief that in a world of uncertainty, Europe must once again answer the call of history. And that is what we must do together,” the German said to lukewarm applause.

Ursula Von der Leyen, during the speech. JULIEN WARNAND EFE The three axes of discourse

Von der Leyen's speech has been built around three axes, but the little emphasis on Ukraine and the war, on military, economic and political support, has been surprising.. Not a mention of President Zelensky, when his wife was the guest of honor last year. The country has been mentioned on different occasions, but the change is very striking. Especially when the president has always been one of the most vocal on the issue.

The first axis of the long intervention has been to take advantage of his management and leadership. His style is enormously presidential, controlling. Everything happens through her and her cabinet. It is not by chance that two of its executive vice presidents, Margrete Vestager and Frans Timmermans, have chosen to seek departures before the end of their mandate.. They had been powerful and influential with Jean-Claude Juncker and she has canceled them. But internal controversies aside, and whether or not it is the best style of human capital management, it is indisputable that Von der Leyen has become the image of the EU. She is indispensable in international forums, she is well-known, she is the person the US knows to call when she picks up the phone.

The management of the pandemic, vaccines and war have been its main assets, and this is what he remembered. “We have seen the birth of a geopolitical Union supporting Ukraine, standing up to Russian aggression, responding to an assertive China and investing in partnerships. We now have a European Green Deal as the centerpiece of our economy and with incomparable ambition. We have led the way for the digital transition and become global pioneers in online rights. We have the historic NextGenerationEU (with 800 billion euros for investment and reforms) and we create decent jobs for today and tomorrow. We have laid the foundations for a Health Union, helping to vaccinate an entire continent (and much of the world). “We have begun to be more independent in critical sectors, such as energy, chips or raw materials,” he listed.

The second axis has been the open challenges. The president of the Commission has spoken in depth about the fight against climate change and the importance of the green transformation, evoking the fires this summer in Spain and Greece or the floods across the continent. He has spoken about biodiversity, gender equality (with a resounding “no means no”) and social dialogue (evoking the famous Val Duchesse meeting that gave rise to the Union).

Competitiveness for companies

The economic part was not the most notable, but he had time to mention persistent inflation, the ECB's policies and the need to alleviate the burden on companies. Not the tax one but the bureaucratic one. “Three challenges such as employment, inflation and the business environment come at a time when we also ask the industry to lead the clean transition. Therefore, we must look further and determine how to remain competitive while doing so.. That is why I have asked Mario Draghi – one of Europe's great economic minds – to prepare a report on the future of European competitiveness.. Because Europe will do “whatever it takes” to maintain its competitive advantage,” he concluded, wasting the opportunity to firmly state that “it will be enough.”. The macro part went unnoticed, but this emphasis has been very popular among business associations.. After years of raising its profile, it has placed the sector, competitiveness, and what needs to be done to strengthen and protect it at the center.. This is what they expected from a leader of the European People's Party.

Artificial intelligence, immigration pact and rule of law

He also spoke at length about the so-called Global Gateway (building more resilient connections with the rest of the world), the corridor through the Middle East towards India, Artificial Intelligence, violence against women, biodiversity, the Rule of Law, the Migration Pact that has been stagnating for a decade but that sees it possible to conclude. Focusing, as usual, on the protection of borders and security and little, in passing, on the drama of the thousands of people who die every year trying to reach the continent. The German defended the controversial agreement with Tunisia, millions of euros and turning a blind eye to its rights violations in exchange for collaboration so that no ships leave (as was already done with Turkey), and asked that it be replicated with others.

The third axis has been what needs to be done, immediately, to answer that “call of history”. You have to open the doors. “Ukraine belongs to the Union, Moldova belongs to the Union, the Balkans belong to the Union,” he enthusiastically stressed.. And that means changing the mentality, but also assuming that deep internal transformations will be necessary, in the decision-making system, budgets or internal functioning.. “In a world where some try to eliminate countries one by one, we cannot afford to leave our European colleagues behind. In a world where size and weight matter, completing our Union is clearly in Europe's strategic and security interests,” he said.

That may require changing the Treaties, a Pandora's box that few want to open. “I will always support this House and all those who want to reform the EU so that it works better for citizens, and yes, that means including changes through a European Convention and Treaty when and where necessary. But we cannot – and we should not wait for the Treaty change to advance with enlargement,” said the German. We must answer the call of history, and we must do it now.

Xi Jinping receives Maduro in Beijing and announces that he will "raise" relations with Venezuela

After an eight-day tour crawling through China in search of an economic lifeline for his country, Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro ended the trip in Beijing on Wednesday, where he was received by his counterpart Xi Jinping.

The leader of the second world power opened the doors of the Great Hall of the People, the Tiananmen chamber where heads of state are usually received, to the Venezuelan to sign a new agreement that will “elevate” relations between both countries.

That on paper translates into a “comprehensive strategic partnership”, a symbolic title, but one that represents the highest level in Chinese diplomacy and which reaches a small list of countries that also include Pakistan or Russia.

Maduro's visit to the capital has allowed the Venezuelan to take a photo with the powerful Chinese boss, but the most fruitful stops, in terms of seeking financing for a country devastated by inflation, which was what he came for, have been in the southern city of Shenzhen and in the financial epicenter Shanghai.

In the latter city, Maduro had a meeting with the president of the BRICS group development bank, former Brazilian president Dilma Rousseff, who supported the dictator by highlighting that the bloc of emerging economies considers Venezuela “a partner, an ally and a friend.” “.

China became a key lender to Venezuela in 2007, when, with Hugo Chávez as president, it injected the Latin American country with funds for ambitious oil and infrastructure projects for the first time.. In the past decade, Beijing, which is Caracas' main creditor, lent around $50 billion to Venezuela, which paid part of the debt with oil shipments.

Maduro's visit shows that both countries are recovering the good tone of their relations after a few years of cooling, and in a current context in which tensions between Beijing and Washington continue to grow.. The meeting between the Chinese and Venezuelan leaders marks the first time the two have sat together in five years.

During his trip, Maduro also tried to win the sympathy of the Chinese people with a visit to one of the country's considered sacred mountains, Taishan, in Shandong province.. A gesture that pleased the state media, which gave extensive coverage.

In Beijing, in addition to the meeting with Xi, the Venezuelan leader also met with the director of the China International Center for Poverty Reduction, Liu Junwen, one of the architects of the development programs that led the Asian country to announce A couple of years ago absolute poverty had been eradicated.

The CNMC now rejects Calviño and rules out sanctioning supermarkets for VAT: "We do not have any competition"

The first vice president of the acting Government, Nadia Calviño, assured at the end of December of last year, in the days prior to the entry into force of the VAT reduction on food, that the National Commission of Markets and Competition (CNMC ) would be the body in charge of monitoring that distribution companies transfer the tax discount to the final prices and, otherwise, would impose sanctions. However, the CNMC now rejects the person responsible for Economic Affairs and assures that it lacks the powers to fine violating companies.

In a resolution to which EL MUNDO has had access, Competition indicates that the Royal Decree-Law by which the VAT reduction was approved “does not confer on the CNMC any power to sanction a possible non-compliance with the provisions of its article 72”. Specifically, this article establishes that “the reduction in the tax rate will fully benefit the consumer, without, therefore, the amount of the reduction being able to be totally or partially dedicated to increasing the business profit margin with the consequent increase in prices in the chain of production, distribution or consumption of products”.

The article also determines that the effectiveness of the measure “will be verified through a system for monitoring the evolution of prices, regardless of the actions that correspond to the National Markets and Competition Commission within the scope of its competencies”. But, in response to the statement made by Calviño on December 28, 2022, the CNMC assures in its letter, dated September 1, 2023, that it does not have powers to sanction possible non-compliance..

Competition thus responds to the consumer association Facua, which since the beginning of this year has been denouncing eight of the main distribution chains – Mercadona, Carrefour, Dia, Alcampo, Lidl, Aldi, Hipercor and Eroski – for the increases they have applied in the prices of a high percentage of foods with reduced VAT. The CNMC defends that any investigation on its part must be framed in the provisions of the Law on the Defense of Competition and that Facua's complaints do not point to any possible infringement of those provided for in said law or to conduct that affects competition. which is its scope of action.

In fact, the Government granted a similar role of surveillance and sanction to the body chaired by Cani Fernández on two previous occasions: in the tax on banks and energy companies, to control that companies do not pass it on to customers, and in the bonus of fuel, to ensure the correct application of the 20 cents per liter. But in none of the cases is there evidence of sanctions because, as in the VAT on food, these are matters that fall outside the scope of Competition.

To the Ministry of Garzón

After the CNMC slammed the door on the matter, Facua has directed its complaints to the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, considering that Alberto Garzón does have the powers to sanction non-compliant companies because they are granted them by the General Law for the Defense of Consumers in its article 47, which defines an infringement as “non-compliance with price regulations (…) or any other type of illegal intervention or action that results in an increase in prices or commercial margins”.

In the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, however, they assure that “price competition was acquired by the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food with the Food Chain Observatory”, a forum in which the different links are represented.. However, in the MAPA they defend that it is “a tax issue” and refer it to the Treasury.. “Economy and Competition drive it,” they say in the department headed by María Jesús Montero.

But, when consulted about the CNMC's letter in which it claims to lack the powers that Calviño attributed to it in its statements, the Ministry of Economic Affairs refers to the report published on July 25 in which Competition confirms that supermarkets yes they are transferring the VAT reduction to the prices. So, at this time, no ministerial department assumes sanctioning competence.

Prices skyrocket

The only person in charge of the Government who has spoken out on the matter has been the Minister of Social Rights, Ione Belarra, who in a message spread through the social network “The Government must act immediately on the price of food, especially olive oil, and if necessary through sanctions”. “We cannot allow speculation with basic food,” he concluded.

The latest monthly analysis by Facua, which is monitoring the evolution of almost a thousand foods affected by the VAT reduction in eight large distribution chains, reflects that nearly half of the products analyzed (48.4%) have increased in price compared to what they marked on December 30 once the tax discount was applied. According to this study, fruits and vegetables lead the increases.

In parallel, the association has focused on olive oil and has asked the Government to “thoroughly investigate the price escalation that is occurring in the sector and apply caps to profit margins in all phases of the chain.” “, since, in his opinion, “the increases are not only a consequence of poor olive harvests, but also of speculation.”