The left to the left of the PSOE has lived for several hours in a kind of return to the years of the process. The commons have cracked this Thursday the strategy of Yolanda Díaz in her campaign for the 23-J elections, stating that the Catalan referendum will form part of her electoral program. The second vice president wants to focus on “things to eat”, on recipes against inflation, against the impact of mortgage increases on families, or on tax matters. No one contemplated that the self-determination of Catalonia would slip back into a campaign for the generals, taking away the focus from the rest of the messages. As long as the consultation has been on the political agenda since the late 1970s.
“In the referendum we are where we have always been. Catalonia must vote on its future. It will form part of our electoral program”, affirmed the number one for Barcelona in the lists of Sumar al Congreso early in the afternoon, returning to the fore a debate that is barely heard outside the territory. “Even ERC has abandoned it a bit,” they assume from one of the forces allied with Díaz.
In Sumar's hard core, they try to contain the damage and explain that the commons will have their own program, although a reduced version of what particularly affects Catalonia will be included among the party's recipes for the State as a whole, as was done in the previous electoral appointments. And there, they maintain, what will be included is not a referendum on self-determination, as they claimed in their day, and as Podemos demanded for years, but that they will bet on the “ratification” of a future agreement, to be specified, that should come out of the dialogue table set up by Pedro Sánchez and Pere Aragonès.
It is a forum that has not met for months, and that in no case will it be possible to reissue if the PP takes over the keys to Moncloa on 23-J. There will be no self-determination referendum in the Sumar program, they insist, only the promise to support the Catalans voting on a hypothetical agreement of the dialogue table. forward kick. “We have been saying the same thing for many years,” they insist. A mere look at the measures defended in the most recent elections allows us to specify this statement. The last program of Unidas Podemos for the general elections, with the common members among its ranks, spoke of a referendum, but specified that the lace of the territory should take place “within Spain”: “We are betting on an agreed referendum in which Podemos will defend a new lace for Catalonia in Spain”, reads the text.
In 2021, Ada Colau's party already recognized an important role for the dialogue table, but they continued to contemplate the referendum, to the point of committing to agree on “a procedure” that would allow “consulting the public about the political future, and that regulates the referendum”. They also promised to “agree on a law to establish the procedure, conditions, qualified majorities and the interpretation of any popular consultation by way of referendum, on the modification of the political status of Catalonia and of the State communities”. They even called for adapting Canada's “law of clarity”, which Pere Aragonès also claimed to apply, articulated in Canada before a possible secession of Quebec that, in the end, did not take place. In September 2021, the commons clearly expressed a shift, focusing on the dialogue table and setting aside the referendum, but in the elections held seven months earlier it was included in their program.
“Catalonia must be able to vote on its future, which is a horizon. Perhaps the difference with other forces is that for us it is not an excuse to continue advancing in many other things,” they say from Ada Colau's party, where they are surprised by the dust generated. Vidal's words at a press conference to present the candidacy, in Sabadell, have not had the same echo in the region that they have achieved in the rest of the State.
In Sumar, they recognize that this framework of debate harms them, since today they are focused on generating illusion and covering the internal noise of the last three weeks, focused on talking about the program. The debate on Catalonia, in addition to the fact that the context is radically different, is dangerously reminiscent of the positions already defended in the past, when Podemos was the hegemonic force of the left to the left of the Socialist Party. The number two of the vice president for Madrid, the diplomat Agustín Santos Maraver, has published articles endorsing self-determination, or considering those convicted of 1-O “political prisoners”.. Díaz wants to avoid this scenario and those terms.
For a formation that claims to be transversal, that appeals to social democratic voters and not just the usual left, and that is allied with regionalist parties such as Más Madrid, that does not enter debates like the Catalan one because it is far away, returning to this framework is score an own goal. Íñigo Errejón, today a deputy for Más País, was among the great defenders of the Catalan referendum, and even of the consultation of 9-N of 2014, “even if there are legal measures against it”. Today he has blurred his positions, as Sumar tries to do. “Yolanda is not going to give her the slightest weight,” says one of the formations aligned with the second vice president. And Díaz has avoided giving it to him until now, resisting revealing his positions in recent years. Nor can it give them votes outside of Catalonia, rather the opposite, nor do they believe that it is among the priorities of the political moment.
Díaz's purge of independence
In drawing up the lists, Yolanda Díaz purged the independence movement. Hence the fall of Jaume Asens, who closes the list for Barcelona in these generals. But the key is ICV. Vidal comes from that political space and is a personal friend of Díaz. Gerardo Pisarello and Gala Pin are not pro-independence, but supporters of an agreed consultation, something that has always been on the left-wing program in Catalonia since 1977, with the PSUC. The key is more personal. Gala Pin, in the past, had even taken care of Ada Colau's children. In the region, but also in others, it is personal relationships that have marked the preparation of the lists. Or the favors for Díaz, such as placing Lilith Verstrynge, secretary of the Podemos Organization, as number four. A difficult toad to swallow for Colau's party.
Sumar does not have very good electoral prospects in Catalonia. Beyond number five in Barcelona, the former councilor in the Catalan capital Eloi Badia —also very close to Colau— or number one for Tarragona, Fèlix Alonso, the rest of the candidates are not expected to win a seat. The forecast is that the campaign for the abstention of the independentistas and the foreseeable departure of the CUP from Congress will benefit the D'Hondt Law, above all, the PSC and the PP.
The commons and their previous political spaces —ICV, the PSUC— have always collected in one way or another a query in their electoral programs. It is a demand that has always been maintained, but has never been vindicated afterwards, not even in Parliament.. That they now advocate “ratifying an agreement that arises from the dialogue table to resolve the question of Catalonia's lace in Spain”, in the words of the spokesman, Ernest Urtasun, does not mean a differential fact with other campaigns. The question is at the moment in which they themselves have put the issue on the table, colliding with the strategy of the second vice president.